Topyaps Logo

Topyaps Logo Topyaps Logo Topyaps Logo Topyaps Logo

Topyaps menu

Responsive image

How Author Hindol Sengupta Exposed The ‘Fake News’ About India’s ‘Tremendous Fall’ In Hunger Index

Published on 15 October, 2017 at 4:18 pm By

Advertisement

In a recent report, the Global Hunger Index (GHI) 2017 showed that India is ranked 100 among 119 countries. The 2017 GHI released by the International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) termed India’s hunger levels a ‘serious’ problem at hand. Its current rank put the country behind less developed countries like Bangladesh and Iraq.

 

Image result for poor india

The Financial Express

The data from the report showed that India ranked lower than all its neighbouring countries – Nepal (72), Myanmar (77), Bangladesh (88), Sri Lanka (84) and China (29) – except Pakistan, which has been placed at 106th in the global hunger list.

The index shows that more than a fifth of Indian children under the age of five are malnourished and weigh too little for their height.


Advertisement

 

Image result for poor india

youthkiawaaz

Not surprisingly, as soon as the report was out, mainstream media latched onto it with some interpreting it as a steep fall of 45 positions. Soon it was a topic of discussion everywhere, especially in the anti-Modi circle.

 

However, author and journalist Hindol Sengupta himself took the initiative to debunk the misleading news reports about the GHI index by mailing IFPRI.

In a Facebook post, Sengupta wrote about the response he received from IFPRI when he asked them to clarify the fall in India’s ranking as was being reported by the media.

 

 

If you are unable to read his Facebook post, here is his complete reply:



Hi Hindol Sengupta

Thank you for your careful and considerate reporting.

Indeed you are correct that the change is due far more to a change in the calculation rather that a change in India’s situation.

The Global Hunger Index (GHI) rankings in 2014 did not include any countries rated with “low” hunger levels (as determined by the report). That year there were 44 such countries, all of which would have ranked above India. Were those countries included in the ranking that year India would have not been ranked 55, but 99.

So to compare the two reports directly and conclude India has fallen 45 positions would be grossly inaccurate and misleading.

While India has for many years been at the higher end of the scale and rated with serious hunger levels, it has also made significant progress in reducing hunger in recent decades. Since 2000 India has reduced it’s GHI score by nearly 20%.

Hunger remains a serious challenge for India, and the GHI demonstrates the country still has quite a long way to go to eliminate hunger. Several of it’s neighbors (Bangladesh and Nepal), have reduced their GHI scores much more than India. An accurate reading of the GHI still shows reason for India be concerned about high hunger levels. But claiming the country has witnessed such a precipitous fall in the global fight to eliminate hunger is very misleading.

We have always been clear about how to interpret GHI data, but if you have further questions please let me know.”

I have attached a screenshot of the email I received from IFPRI to this post. Everyone can see the name of the IFPRI representative who wrote back to me.

Every news organisation that made this their headline knew that this was false – or they have absolutely incompetent editors. One of the two must be correct. Yet, it went viral.

This is the state of #FakeNews in India. Even in an issue as serious as hunger. Many people and organisations owe an apology to their audience for this.

Read this part of the email again:

The Global Hunger Index (GHI) rankings in 2014 did not include any countries rated with “low” hunger levels (as determined by the report). That year there were 44 such countries, all of which would have ranked above India. Were those countries included in the ranking that year India would have not been ranked 55, but 99.


Advertisement

So, the jury is out on whether it is a case of media manipulation or merely erroneous reporting.

Advertisement

Latest Stories

Kashmiri Youth’s Message To Pakistan is Loud And Clear, As 3000 Turn Up For Indian Army Posts

Kashmiri Youth’s Message To Pakistan is Loud And Clear, As 3000 Turn Up For Indian Army Posts


Kulbhushan Jadhav Case: Netizens React To Pakistan Quoting Articles In Indian Media In ICJ

Kulbhushan Jadhav Case: Netizens React To Pakistan Quoting Articles In Indian Media In ICJ


WTF? Chennai Man Orders Food, Swiggy Employee Picks It Up From A Restaurant In Rajasthan!

WTF? Chennai Man Orders Food, Swiggy Employee Picks It Up From A Restaurant In Rajasthan!


Pakistani Flags Appear When People Search For ‘Best Toilet Paper In The World.’ Google Denies Report

Pakistani Flags Appear When People Search For ‘Best Toilet Paper In The World.’ Google Denies Report


SRK Becomes Victim Of Fake News On Social Media, Fans Start #StopFakeNewsAgainstSRK

SRK Becomes Victim Of Fake News On Social Media, Fans Start #StopFakeNewsAgainstSRK


Advertisement

Most Searched

More From India

Popular on The Web